Sophisticated stock investors are always on the hunt for investment strategies that can help them outperform the stock market. Using the “smart beta” approach is one way that has grown popular during the last few years. It’s a kind of factor investing, which aims to create above-market returns for those who use the strategy.
Put simply, smart beta is index investing with a twist: Using exchange-traded funds (ETFs), investors try to beat a benchmark index (like the S&P 500) rather than simply match the benchmark’s performance as with traditional index investing.
That said, it isn’t suited for every investor. Smart-beta ETFs charged higher fees (expense ratios) than regular ETFs, and many don’t outperform their benchmarks. But some do beat. And that’s what attracts investors.
Smart Beta vs. Index Investing
Index investing is passive investing, meaning you buy into an index fund that tracks the performance of the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA). You sit back and watch your investment rise or fall in sequence with its benchmark index.
And there are hundreds of indices in which to invest. Some track the collective performance of thousands of companies worldwide. Meanwhile, others only follow a tiny pool of players in an emerging niche sector.
The beauty of index investing is that while you won’t beat your benchmark, you’ll never underperform it.
Smart beta is a form of passive investing, but it goes a step further by giving investors opportunities to exploit certain performance factors that could help beat a benchmark.
With standard index investing, many broad-based indices consist of both popular and poorly performing companies, so too many laggards can suppress returns. And many traditional index funds and ETFs are “capitalization-weighted,” meaning that individual stocks within an index are weighted more heavily than stocks with lower capitalizations.
But this distorts the true value of the index because a handful of highly valued stocks can end up representing a disproportionate percentage of the index’s total value.
Smart-beta guru Rob Arnott put it best to CNBC: “Smart beta is a rules-based, systematic, transparent, low-cost way of accessing the market… Smart beta avoids the pit falls of market-cap weighting, which tends to overweight overvalued securities and underweight undervalued ones.”
How Smart Beta Works
With smart beta, you can create an investment portfolio with custom-built indices that filter out laggards and highly valued stocks (expensive, in other words) while focusing on stocks of companies with certain factors such as long histories of superior profits, strong balance sheets, stable cash flows, and Steady Eddie stock performance.
These factors are typically defined as value, quality, momentum, and low volatility.
Smart beta allows investors to allocate and rebalance portfolio holdings to lower risk and improve returns by relying on one or more of these factors and subfactors (300 in all).
Smart-beta funds have cousins called quant funds, which also use custom-built indices. However, quants employ complex math formulas (quantitative analysis and algorithms) to select the fund’s investments.
Smart-beta investing shouldn’t be confused with “active management,” in which mutual fund managers disregard indices and instead pick individual stocks or sectors (health care, tech, etc.) in hopes of beating the major U.S. benchmarks like the S&P 500, DJIA, or Nasdaq.
For the record, actively managed funds carry high fees, and over the long run, they rarely beat their benchmarks. Just think of smart beta as the middle ground between passive and active investing.
Understanding the Theory
This is where it gets a bit technical. None of this is a science. It’s a theory that’s been around since the early 1990s and become popular in the aftermath of the 2008–2009 financial crisis.
But the term “beta” has been around a lot longer. Beta measures a stock’s sensitivity (volatility) to the movement of the overall stock market.
Let’s start with the almighty S&P 500, an index that measures the daily changes among 500 large U.S. companies. The S&P 500 index’s beta, expressed numerically, is 1.0. A stock with a beta of 1.0 tells investors the stock moves in correlation with the index. A beta of less than 1.0 indicates the stock is less volatile than the index.
Keep in mind that individual stocks tend to be more volatile than their index — and smart-beta strategies are designed to exploit this volatility.
For example, let’s say a stock has a beta of 1.2, which means the stock is 20 percent more volatile than the overall market. Smart-beta theory would suggest that if the S&P 500 increased 10 percent, that stock would rise by 12 percent. Get it? This works the same in reverse if the market is falling.
Investors — typically active investors — also can be guided by another common term: “alpha.” This measures a fund’s ability (or rather that of the fund’s portfolio manager) to outperform an index.
What’s the Smart-Beta Track Record?
To be honest, the evidence is mixed when trying to figure out if smart beta works or not. A 2019 study found that factor investing (which includes smart beta strategies) between 1995 and 2018 outperformed the S&P 500 by up to 2.5 percent. Wow. But how accurate is that study?
To get a true performance picture, just compare individual smart-beta ETFs against the S&P 500 index Sometimes smart beta works, sometimes it doesn’t. Do your homework to find the fund that best suits your goals and risk tolerance — not to mention your wallet.
The Bottom Line
If you’re a novice investor, forget about it. Go simple indexing investing (passive) with low-cost ETFs or index (mutual) funds. Don’t try to beat the index.
However, if you’re experienced at investing and can afford to take some risks, smart-beta or active investing could benefit you. If you work with a robo-adviser, it’s very likely you are already invested in some smart-beta ETFs. Just expect to pay much higher fees, which could, in the end, negate your gains.
Keep in mind that smart-beta funds operate on past performance. They can get walloped when market conditions change for the worse.
When the stock market is producing higher than average returns, the idea of using more costly smart-beta funds to eke out a little more return seems foolish. When the stock market starts manifesting returns of a measly 3 to 5 percent, that’s the time for smart-beta funds to prove their true value.