On multiple occasions, I’ve mentioned the financial services industry’s incredible ability to confuse everyone – seriously, everyone. My goal is to help make a little bit of sense out of the mumbo jumbo in hopes that it helps people make better decisions. In previous series, we discussed basic investing and financial planning.
We recently started an asset allocation series to build up the foundation of your financial literacy house. In Part One of the series, we discussed what asset allocation is and why it’s important, and provided an overview of some common asset allocation strategies (one of which was not a get-rich-quick scheme). Today we will do a deeper dive into each of the four most common asset allocation strategies: strategic, dynamic, tactical, and core-satellite.
Strategic Asset Allocation
Strategic asset allocation (SAA) is a long-term approach that is designed to minimize the impact of emotions on portfolios. The goal is to create an appropriate mix of investments that balance risk and long-term returns.
The concept suggests that investors will benefit by staying invested in the markets and adhering to target allocations that reflect characteristics of the investor, rather than the performance of specific investments.
When the market is volatile, are you a Snoopy Joe Cool type, or are you more of a doom and gloom Charlie Brown type? Target allocation percentages for various asset classes (e.g. bonds, U.S. stocks, international stocks…) are selected based on the investor’s comfort level with risk, time horizon, and investment objectives. As those items change, the allocations may change, as well. The portfolio allocations are monitored periodically. Then, as the allocation percentages drift from the targets – as the markets go up and down – the allocations are rebalanced back to the risk aligned target percentages. It’s a more passive strategy that doesn’t change based on economic conditions.
Dynamic Asset Allocation
Dynamic asset allocation (DAA) is similar to strategic asset allocation in that both set target allocation percentages of asset classes. However, dynamic allocations may have several short-term adjustments to those allocations based on current and expected market and economic conditions. When using DAA, the focus is typically on the absolute return, not on comparing to an index/benchmark. Investors and managers who use dynamic asset allocation can achieve high returns if they are right regarding their assumptions on what the market will do. Obviously that is easier said than done, especially in flat and down markets. Pay attention to trading costs if you (or your advisor) use DAA, as it can get expensive.
Tactical Asset Allocation
Tactical asset allocation (TAA) is a more active approach. It involves constantly evaluating specific investments, looking for opportunities to take advantage of undervalued or overvalued assets. Those who use this strategy are typically looking for shorter-term gains from market inefficiencies where the market overreacted to something, though the investments could be held longer.
TAA proponents essentially act as appraisers, using fundamental and technical analysis of the investment, markets, and economic conditions to evaluate the value of an investment. If it appears to be undervalued, they buy it. If it appears to be overvalued, they sell it. Use caution here – if you’re investing outside of a retirement account, you should be aware of the tax implications of the shorter-term gains. Most people who use TAA have significant investing experience, as well as access to a lot of economic data.
Core-Satellite Asset Allocation
Core-satellite asset allocation involves launching a satellite into space that will manage your money while simultaneously strengthening your core…
Ok, not true, but it would be epic if it were! One part Elon Musk, one part Warren Buffet, one part Arnold (I won’t even attempt to spell his last name). Shaken, not stirred. Epic, I say – epic! But I digress… again.
Core-satellite asset allocation is a hybrid approach. There is a fundamental core to your portfolio, which serves as the foundation. The core portion will be more long-term strategic asset allocation (potentially dynamic asset allocation) tied to your individual risk tolerance. The satellite portion of the portfolio will consist of shorter-term, more tactical allocations. The more seasoned the investor, the more she may lean towards a larger satellite allocation. The more novice investor should probably lean towards a larger core allocation.
Hopefully now you have a basic understanding of asset allocation. There are a lot of different strategies out there, and picking the right one for you comes down to your personality, how involved you want to be, and a good advisor guiding you.